Your question has been sent.
Expect an answer!
755 Us 22, Phillipsburg, NJ 08865, Phillipsburg
Yes, cash only
It's old school like that.
Do you serve anything but pizza are there more then one size pizza
This is your Typical Pizzeria , The Pizza is a Local Tradition. One of the Oldest in the Phillipsburg Area . They make an Excellent Traditional pie the Sicilian pizza has a great crust. Still family run.
There is a reason this is the oldest pizzeria in NJ. I still haven't found better pizza anywhere! I'll always go back.
Pizza, only pizza. The place hasn’t changed for at least 30 years. The pizza is still good. They put the cheese on last. So, if you order a topping like pepperoni they cove it with the cheese. I don’t think it makes a difference in the taste it’s just something I haven’t seen before.
Great traditional pizza.
This is the best pizza I've ever had!! When ever I return 'home', we go to Nicolosi's for the amazing pizza! It is always made quickly. The crust is thin. The sauce is soooo good!! They use a lot of cheese. There is no need for toppings because the pizza is THAT good. They have only pizza and drinks. The restaurant is informal. They deliver as well. There are no public bathrooms on the premises. The facilities are clean.
Haven't had pizza this good in years! Best pizza in town!
Great pizza it's a must have but don't forget to take cash that's the only way to pay and it's there way to cut cost so they don't have to over charge for good pizza.
Best pizza in town. Always has been.
The best pizza in Phillipsburg, NJ. Period. It has been there since 1964, and still goes strong. The employees are friendly, and service is quick.
Old style pizza shop. Everyone loves Nicolosi's pizza. You won't be disappointed.
The pizza was good. But they serve no other food, which is very strange in these days. If you want a good pizza it's good for the area in Phillipsburg
This has been my favorite pizza place since I was a child. Every bite is a taste of childhood to me. I live 30 min anyway and will still drive to come here. Staff are always friendly. And I never had a slice of pizza that wasn't great.
3rd generation of family to be raised on the best pizza not only in Jersey but in the USA. They are the oldest pizzeria in New Jersey for a reason...You have tried the rest now try the best... Just pizza and only cash. They do have an ATM. Nicolossi's is by far the best so go find this Gem.
Good and friendly service
Didn't like customer service. Felt out of place. Everyone stairing at my coworker and I. Also pizza was flimsy.
Good pizza. Nothing stand out except they do really good bacon w the topoi gs under the cheese. Old school shop feel and a pretty good sauce. It's located in the middle of a business type park and doesn't have a public bathroom and you'll be hard pressed to find a public one nearby.
Great gluten free pizza! They even gave me .y own pizza cutter so there would be no contamination! I had yet to find authentic italian gf pizza, but I'm happy to say after years of searching, I found it!
Great pizza as always.
Nicolosi's pizza seems to be a local favorite. There's a pleasant atmosphere with some impressive baseball memorabilia adorning the walls. I went with a standard plain slice, as there wasn't much selection at the time I decided to stop by. The slice was greasy but had a good cheese to sauce ratio, both of which were tasty. The base and crust were the right amounts of crispy. And while I prefer my slices come unseasoned so that I may add them myself if necessary, the slice came with a good ratio of spices that weren't too overpowering.
I just got a pizza to go,I dont know where they get their cheese but it was horrible.ive gotten pizza in the past and never like this.
The only thing better than paying taxes is eating a Nicolosi pizza!
Best pizza in pburg. Cash only
DELICIOUS pizza. The guys over the phone were helpful with my order. Ordered a large cheese pizza, extra cheese, half pepperoni and they put the pepperoni between the cheese! It was delectable! Highly recommend, just ignore the owner and his bad attitude. Customer service sucks, and has likely drained him.
I think this is the best pizza in town.it is a little more expensive more than the other places but for the extra dollar to it's worth it
Man!!! This is the best pizza place I have ever been to with the best pizza out the all the states I've ever been!!!!
This place has been my preference for pizza. 45 years and still coming back. Yes I do eat at other pizza shops. But if I'm close, Nicolosi's is my spot. Must try to rate your preference of taste.
Really good pizza. The staff are really friendly. I've been eating Nicolosi's for as long as I can remember. Really nice local place to get a great slice for a good price.
The best pizza around!!!! A must try if your in the town
Hands-down, best hometown pizza ever!!!!! Family owned forever. Great homemade sauce!
Best NY style pizza in area
Bare-bones excellent pizza. Cash-only.It's what you crave, simple and good.
Best pizza growing up, and I've yet to find a rival in all my travels. I still bring back a pie home to NY for friends, per their request. The uninitiated should be prepared: no bathrooms, cash only, and only pizza...but you'll be hooked for life!
Pizza is just outstanding. The sauce, crispness of the crust, just enough grease (not too much) make it a pie to rival any in NYC, which is why New Jerseyans know the best pizzas are in NJ.
Best pizza around. Been going there since it opened.i live in Easton now and will go there before any other place.
Best Pizza place in the world! I Love their pizza and everyone should eat here! :)
Super delicious. Crispy crust, saucy and cheesey... The pepperoni, sausage and bacon pizza hit the spot! Found my new favorite pizza place 😁
Consistently a perfect pie! Nearly 40 years of eating Nicolosi’s, I still crave it when I’m out of town. Order a plain pie well done & dream about it after it’s gone.
The pizza dough was so soggy I really try for the first time 10 years ago.. i never came back again. So after 10 years I tried again because my 2 other favorite pizza was closed for summer vacations and my opinions is the same.
If I could give them 10 stars it wouldn't be enough. I moved out of the area over 20 years ago but when ever I get the chance I get Nicolosi's. There will never be another pizza that even comes close to theirs.
Their pizza has been consistent for as long as I can remember. You absolutely can't go wrong, this place is a local treasure.
Cash only, pizza falls apart when you're trying to eat it. Everyone raves about this place but I don't get it. I think its bland.
Good pizza, nice people, pleasant interior.
The pizza is perfect and it’s no wonder why Nicolosi’s is the longest running pizzeria in Jersey. Sicilian and regular pizza is the only thing on the menu since 1964 which is probably why they are so good at it. The pizza has a perfect blend of a great homemade sauce with really good cheese topped off with a very good amount of oregano. The flavor brings you back to how really really good pizza tasted back in the day. The location is family owned and the family and staff are always friendly and greet you as soon as you walk in. Nicolosi’s also delivers and is the fastest at it too. Generally less than 30 minutes or less from the time you order. I highly highly recommend trying Nicolosi’s if you are a pizza lover!
Best pizza in phillipsburg..... some would argue it's the best pizza anywhere
Real good pizza. They only have pizza and they are cash only. You can't really see the place from the parking lot, so it's a little hard to find. Owner seemed nice - asked me how I liked it as I left. Lots of foot traffic on a Saturday afternoon.
Absolutely the best mom and pop pizzeria in town!I was recently back in town to visit family and thrilled to see this place was still open. After a decade on the west coast with less than spectacular pizza, there was no way I could leave again without grabbing a slice or two. Both slices were the perfect shot of hometown pride that I needed. Delicious!
The dirtiest pizza shop I've ever been in. No matter how good their food is cleanliness priority for me. From the cash register, to the food warmer , to the oven to the floor runner all covered in old grease & dust. Guy serving me a slice is handling a filthy cash register and serving food. If this place should get inspected I'm sure they will fail. Restaurant smells like my auto mechanic shop.
Great pizza with a smile!
Great pizza place! The sauce especially is top notch.
The best pizza around. Not too greasy, not overcooked.. just perfectly delicious.
Your question has been sent.
Expect an answer!
Your review has been submitted.
Want to order over the phone?
Thank you for being with us!
We will call you back!